Skip to Main Content

We printed a newsletter. Now we’re emailing it.

The print edition of The Takeback, now online: the $800M returns bill, five returns mistakes, and how AI agents read your return policy.

Issue 15: Special Edition

You saw it on the socials. You read it in the news. If you were at RetailClub you might have held it in your hot little hands. Earlier this fall we created an old school black-ink-on-your fingers version of our newsletter and today we’re bringing it to your email. 

The people have spoken.

“The Takeback isn’t just a newsletter, it’s the most entertaining thing in loss prevention. Actually, it’s the ONLY entertaining thing in loss prevention.”
– Jim in Cubicle 5

“Now at dinner parties I always have something interesting to say about fraud and abuse. Thanks, The Takeback.”
– The CFO you didn’t invite to your dinner party

“Fraudsters run when they see me reading it.”
– Marcy “the receipt warden” Jones, Store Operations Manager

Now quick, forward this to anyone on your team who’s bored by the standard industry reports in their inbox.

Dog reading The Takeback

Want your very own printed edition?
Reply to this email with your address. Your real one. Where mail comes.

 

The Takeback Talks

The Takeback Talks

Every other month in this curated invitation-only community, leaders across LP, finance, operations, ecommerce, and IT meet for virtual, candid, closed-door discussions on the full picture of retail loss.

On December 10th, Vishal Patel, Appriss’s Chief Product and AI Officer, and Jeremy Brown, Chief Operating Officer at Ardene, will lead a conversation on the Q4 Halftime. Designed for Tech and Store Ops leaders, this session puts your holiday stack on the table while the results are still fresh: where it cracked under peak volume, what you can prove to Finance before 2027 budgets lock, and what you’d say if someone challenged a call your AI made during Black Friday week.

Interested in joining the Takeback Talks? Request an invitation.

Can’t wait for our next edition?

Can’t wait for our next edition?

We’re spilling the tea from an amazing conversation with Jesus Mathus, a recently retired chief information officer (CIO) who ran IT at three regional grocery chains.

Oh you want a little taste to get excited?

Here’s a quote from Jesus: “We did not have an AI strategy. We had a business strategy that drove the IT strategy, and we used AI in those IT priorities whenever it made sense”

We’ll see you right here next time to dive into Jesus’s advice, backed by three decades in retail tech. (Get ahead, forward to your IT folks now)

Today's Shrink Forecast

Today's Shrink Forecast

forecast

Nobody at your company has seen the full returns bill

Nobody at your company has seen the full returns bill

Antonio ColicchioA $4 billion retailer can be carrying roughly $800 million in returns, split across supply chain, digital, customer care, merchandising, and inventory. Antonio Colicchio estimates 30 to 50 percent of those returns are controllable, and he lays out three questions CFOs should ask before approving the next budget request.  

The ick list

The ick list

the ick list
Retailers keep making the same mistakes. 


Here’s what NOT to do if you want to take back your margins and get a handle on Total Retail Loss:  

  • Institute blanket return policies that don’t allow refunds without a receipt, blocking all $68B in unreceipted returns just to reach the fraud hiding inside a fraction of it 
  • Treat abuse and fraud as the same problem, when abuse is 6x bigger ($86B vs $14B) and looks like normal behavior 
  • Proudly roll out static thresholds a fraudster learns in a week and your best customer gets caught in by accident 
  • Scroll through mountains of exceptions every Monday and work the cases that are easiest to close, not the ones bleeding the most profit 
  • Spend hours building manual shrink reports and dashboards to understand where losses happen after that money has already walked out the door

TRL “Cribs”

TRL “Cribs”

Vishal Patel

Vishal Patel, Appriss’s Chief Product & AI Officer, breaks down the 3-layer architecture that powers Appriss’s AI-driven returns reduction: 

3 layer architecture

Ground floor: the foundation. Data intelligence handles identity resolution across cards, emails, phone numbers, and (most importantly) channels. 

Middle floor: the structural support. Machine learning models score the unified data based on risk then approve, warn, or decline in under one second with 99.99% accuracy.  

Top floor: the penthouse. Workflow intelligence (Sidekick, for Appriss customers) provides plain-language explanations of the data that drove the decision. 

To read more about how to handle cracks in your stack foundation (and keep the penthouse looking fly), read the full issue.


pointing at youWe need YOU for our next issue
Know an expert in loss prevention, IT, finance, ecommerce, or store ops who you think we should feature in The Takeback? Refer them (or yourself) here.

Did you know?

Did you know?

In 2025, consumers made $706B in returns, and retailers faced $89B in loss from shrink, much of it preventable 

One Director of Loss Prevention at an 11K-location quickserve chain 3x’d productivity by taking a different approach to alerts 

Agents are forecast to drive 8–15% of European ecommerce spend by 2030, and that channel isn’t going to wait for an owner.  


Your system isn’t ready for agentic returns.

An AI agent reads your return policy in full, then returns the order right at the edge of what’s allowed. Faking photos of a damaged item takes seconds now. None of it trips a fraud flag, because none of it breaks a rule — and behavior that stays inside policy is costing retailers $86B, versus $14B for outright fraud. 

“Today AI agents can go review all these policies, summarize what are the loopholes in them, and tell you the exact boundaries you can stay within to not be flagged at a certain retailer,” says Patel. 

Read the full playbook on who owns agentic commerce fraud. 

Don’t stop here

Don’t stop here

If you like what you read and want your own print edition, reply to this email. Refer a friend (or yourself) to be a featured SME in a future issue, or just forward this email to a colleague who’s hungry for insights, but bored by the standard format.  

The Archive

Here’s what you missed.

Stay informed

Monthly insights on the loss you can actually control.